AMSA conducted a Safety of Navigation Focused Inspection Campaign (FIC) over the period 1 August to the 8 September 2021 and found that a significant number of ships failed to comply to basic navigation safety requirements.
More specifically, the campaign focussed on:
- The level of compliance with the safety of navigation requirements of International Conventions;
- The familiarity of the master and officers with their processes for ensuring safety of navigation.
The campaign took place as a core part of AMSA’s Compliance Plan for 2021/22 and was scheduled for two months with a target of 200 inspections. Lockdowns in various states, and restrictions implemented to protect AMSA staff and the Australian public meant that AMSA ceased the campaign early on 8 September 2021, after exceeding its target of 200 inspections.
Results
The FIC results showed that a significant number of ships failed to comply to basic navigation safety requirements. The results were as follows:
- 278 ships were inspected during the FIC.
- AMSA detained 21 ships during the period of the FIC, 7 of which were directly attributed to the safety of navigation FIC. This shows that 33.33% of all detentions during the FIC related to safety of navigation. This is extremely concerning.
Moreover, further key results of the FIC showed that:
- 63 (23%) vessels were found to have bridge visibility obstructed by cargo gear or other obstructions forward of the beam. Not all observations resulted in a deficiency, with Inspectors noting that some obstructions were minor in nature and did not warrant the issuing of a deficiency,
- 16 (6%) vessels had not executed and monitored their previous voyage in accordance with the approved passage plan,
- 11 (4%) vessels SMSs did not contain guidance on best practice watchkeeping, including appropriate Under Keel Clearance (UKC) and safety contour settings;
- 9 (3%) vessels failed to properly appraise the passage plan prior to its execution, or have the passage plan available on both primary and back-up systems.
Whilst some of the results above are low by percentage, the consequence of these deficiencies can be severe resulting in collision, grounding, and significant pollution incidents.
On the positive side, the most positive results were that the majority of vessels:
- Are using up to date Official Electronic Nautical Charts (99%);
- Have the required inputs to ECDIS connected and configured correctly (Gyro, Continuous position fixing system and speed and distance measure device) (97%);
- Maintain a proper lookout in accordance with the COLREGs (98%);
- Test navigation equipment to ensure its proper operation (98%).
Taking into consideration the results of the campaign, AMSA intends to:
- Increase its focus on safety of navigation onboard ships that navigate in Australian waters and arrive at Australian ports;
- Undertake this campaign again in 12-18 months’ time.
With this report in mind, I wonder what percentage of crowded (say 2,000/5,000 pax) cruise ships are within these significant number of ships which failed to comply?