Subscribe to our Mailing Lists (It's free!)
Tuesday, July 15, 2025
SAFETY4SEA
  • Home
  • Safety
    • All
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
    2024 IMO Bravery Awards honor tanker and tugboat crews for heroic acts

    Officer to receive IMO bravery award for saving 12 crew members

    Panama

    BMA: Sanctions imposed against Russia

    Work,Safety,Concept.,Wooden,Cube,Blocks,With,Icon,Of,Safety

    DNV: Key IMO safety developments

    seafarers

    Philippines DMW issues call to protect seafarers from warlike areas

  • SEAFiT
    • All
    • Intellectual
    • Mental
    • Physical
    • Social
    • Spiritual
    friendship

    Exploring the human need for friendship: A lifeline at sea and on shore

    neck pain

    Neck pain: A growing health concern for maritime workers

    Book Review: Building leaders the MMMA way

    Book Review: Feel grounded and think positive in 10 simple steps

    time

    Stay SEAFiT: Time is non-renewable – invest it wisely

  • Green
    • All
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
    ammonia bunkering vessel

    Company orders ammonia bunkering vessel for use in Singapore

    WSC

    WSC proposes alignment of EU ETS with IMO Net Zero Framework

    IMO Council World Maritime Day

    IMO: World Maritime Day two-year theme to take policy to practice

    BIMCO FuelEU Maritime Regulation

    EU issues low-carbon hydrogen fuel standards

  • Smart
    • All
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
    vr training

    Companies team up for virtual reality training to better prepare crew

    digital tools onboard

    Company signs for AI autonomous navigation system for PCTC fleet

    Trafigura, ZeroNorth join forces to advance decarbonization solutions

    Trafigura, ZeroNorth join forces to advance decarbonization solutions

    floating data centres

    New partnership to develop floating data center on retrofitted vessel

  • Risk
    • All
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Focus
    • Vetting
    AMSA fine

    NorthStandard: Tips to avoid pollution fines in Turkey

    OCIMF

    OCIMF Annual Report 2025: SIRE 2.0 a welcome change for the industry

    USCG

    ABS PSC Report Q1 2025: 526 total vessels detained

    paris mou lists

    Paris MoU 2024 Performance lists

  • Others
    • All
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
    China

    China lays out vision for smarter and greener shipping

    Sanctions Russia

    EU plans to impose new Russian oil price cap

    EU US

    US plans to hit EU and Mexico with 30% tariff starting August

    Dr. Rosalie Balkin

    Dr. Rosalie Balkin to receive IMO International Maritime Prize

  • Columns
    Career Paths: Syb ten Cate Hoedemaker, Maritime Battery Forum

    Career Paths: Syb ten Cate Hoedemaker, Maritime Battery Forum

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    NorthStandard: Data sharing to drive technology and improve crew wellbeing

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    Trending Tags

    • Anchor Your Health
    • Book Review
    • Career Paths
    • Human Performance
    • Industry Voices
    • Interviews
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Regulatory Update
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
    • Training & Development
    • Wellness Corner
    • Wellness Tips
  • Events
  • Plus
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Safety
    • All
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
    2024 IMO Bravery Awards honor tanker and tugboat crews for heroic acts

    Officer to receive IMO bravery award for saving 12 crew members

    Panama

    BMA: Sanctions imposed against Russia

    Work,Safety,Concept.,Wooden,Cube,Blocks,With,Icon,Of,Safety

    DNV: Key IMO safety developments

    seafarers

    Philippines DMW issues call to protect seafarers from warlike areas

  • SEAFiT
    • All
    • Intellectual
    • Mental
    • Physical
    • Social
    • Spiritual
    friendship

    Exploring the human need for friendship: A lifeline at sea and on shore

    neck pain

    Neck pain: A growing health concern for maritime workers

    Book Review: Building leaders the MMMA way

    Book Review: Feel grounded and think positive in 10 simple steps

    time

    Stay SEAFiT: Time is non-renewable – invest it wisely

  • Green
    • All
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
    ammonia bunkering vessel

    Company orders ammonia bunkering vessel for use in Singapore

    WSC

    WSC proposes alignment of EU ETS with IMO Net Zero Framework

    IMO Council World Maritime Day

    IMO: World Maritime Day two-year theme to take policy to practice

    BIMCO FuelEU Maritime Regulation

    EU issues low-carbon hydrogen fuel standards

  • Smart
    • All
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
    vr training

    Companies team up for virtual reality training to better prepare crew

    digital tools onboard

    Company signs for AI autonomous navigation system for PCTC fleet

    Trafigura, ZeroNorth join forces to advance decarbonization solutions

    Trafigura, ZeroNorth join forces to advance decarbonization solutions

    floating data centres

    New partnership to develop floating data center on retrofitted vessel

  • Risk
    • All
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Focus
    • Vetting
    AMSA fine

    NorthStandard: Tips to avoid pollution fines in Turkey

    OCIMF

    OCIMF Annual Report 2025: SIRE 2.0 a welcome change for the industry

    USCG

    ABS PSC Report Q1 2025: 526 total vessels detained

    paris mou lists

    Paris MoU 2024 Performance lists

  • Others
    • All
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
    China

    China lays out vision for smarter and greener shipping

    Sanctions Russia

    EU plans to impose new Russian oil price cap

    EU US

    US plans to hit EU and Mexico with 30% tariff starting August

    Dr. Rosalie Balkin

    Dr. Rosalie Balkin to receive IMO International Maritime Prize

  • Columns
    Career Paths: Syb ten Cate Hoedemaker, Maritime Battery Forum

    Career Paths: Syb ten Cate Hoedemaker, Maritime Battery Forum

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    NorthStandard: Data sharing to drive technology and improve crew wellbeing

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    GSR Services: The Hong Kong Convention sets the rules for total ship lifecycle responsibility

    Trending Tags

    • Anchor Your Health
    • Book Review
    • Career Paths
    • Human Performance
    • Industry Voices
    • Interviews
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Regulatory Update
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
    • Training & Development
    • Wellness Corner
    • Wellness Tips
  • Events
  • Plus
No Result
View All Result
SAFETY4SEA

Who is to blame for the repeated occurrence of accidents in enclosed space?

by Capt. Zhao Qingwei
May 23, 2022
in Opinions
Enclosed space entry

Above image is used for illustration purposes only / Credit: Videotel

FacebookTwitterEmailLinkedin

Enclosed space accidents have always been a major headache for the shipping industry. Although the industry has taken many precautions, the fatalities keep repeating itself, argues Capt. Zhao, Marine Safety Manager of DASIN Singapore based shipping company.

According to the IG P&I Club, of the 83 fatalities in enclosed spaces that occurred between 2015 and 2020, 53% of the deaths were due to oxygen depletion and over 60% of the incidents were located in the cargo hold. The International Dry Bulk Terminals Group (DBTG) has had statistics of over 70 accidents during the transportation or loading of solid bulk cargoes between 1999 and April 2018. Of these, 88 people lost their lives due to asphyxiation or carbon monoxide poisoning, with 76 of them dying on ladders in the ship’s hold passages. A further nine people died in the cargo area and three died in the adjacent foredeck space. According to OSHA, 89% of confined space fatalities occur on work authorized by a supervisor and 80% of fatalities occur in locations once entered by the same person who later died.

A lot of efforts have been made by the shipping community to avoid accidents in enclosed spaces, with IMO requiring regular closed space entry drills under SOLAS Chapter 3, and a PSC CIC in 2015 by the Tokyo and Paris Memorandum specifically for closed space entry and rescue. And the results of the inspections were relatively satisfactory, e.g. The results of the Paris MOU CIC showed that seafarers generally had a good understanding of risks and procedures, scoring above 90% in most categories except for crew members’ familiarity with their duties (88%) and the absence of a manual on board (83%). Similar results were found for Tokyo MOU’s 2015 CIC.

RelatedNews

Watch: Avoid the risk of electrocution for shipboard welding

Crew member jailed for modifying mask linked to colleague’s death

In accident investigations, we often find that most enclosed space accidents are attributed to human error, usually the fault of the crew, but rarely do we blame shore management/supervision. With respect to closed compartments, there may also be safety hazards as follows:

Are the enclosed spaces well marked and protected?

As per IMO Resolution A.1050(27) , Enclosed space means a space which has any of the following characteristics:

.1 limited openings for entry and exit;
.2 inadequate ventilation; and
.3 is not designed for continuous worker occupancy,

and includes, but is not limited to, cargo spaces, double bottoms, fuel tanks, ballast tanks, cargo pump-rooms, cargo compressor rooms, cofferdams, chain lockers, void spaces, duct keels, inter-barrier spaces, boilers, engine crankcases, engine scavenge air receivers, sewage tanks, and adjacent connected spaces. This list is not exhaustive and a list should be produced on a ship-by-ship basis to identify enclosed spaces.

In the eyes of the shore management, the above description of enclosed spaces should be understood by the crew. But on board, most of the people who are actually engaged in the closed spaces operation are ordinary crew members, and I’m sure they don’t know the exact rules, especially for new crew members. If the closed spaces on board are not marked with warning signs, the crew will not know which is the closed spaces, because in the crew’s concept, the closed compartments should be ballast tanks, oil tanks, void tanks, etc., which are closed for a long time and need temporary access during inspection. The crew does not have much idea about the cargo spaces, the duct keel and other compartments with square manhole cover, which are very easy to open. The above areas are very dangerous if there are no relevant warning signs.

Also mentioned in the rules, when there is no need to enter the closed spaces, the doors and hatches leading to the closed spaces should always be locked to prevent access. But at present, we are more concerned about the steps to enter the closed space and rescue procedures, few people to pay attention to the closed space marking and protection. And it is precisely because many crew members “breakthrough” the first line of defense, only to cause fatal consequences later.

I wonder if the shore personnel have paid attention to the following details during the audit and inspection/check:

  • Are the ship’s self-defined enclosed compartments checked against the ship’s structure?
  • Does the list of enclosed compartments on board meet the requirements?
  • Are the relevant enclosed compartments marked with warnings?
  • Are the enclosed compartments protected against accidental entry?

STCW Training System

Many accidents are basically due to the lack of safety awareness of crew members. We all know that crew members need to get the required certificates before they go on board, one of which is ” Basic Safety Training Certificate”, And this training included the requirements related to closed spaces. But if a crew member is on board a ship for the first time and immediately goes to work without timely familiarization training on personal safety, the risks he faces can be imagined.

The number of gas detectors equipped

A gas detector is currently required on board according to SOLAS Convention XI-1/7. (IMO Resolution A.1050(27) does not have an explicit requirement for the number of gas detectors, but does specify that testing should be conducted before personnel enter the enclosed spaces and at regular intervals thereafter until all work is completed. In addition, the resolution also requires the atmosphere of the space has been tested as appropriate with properly calibrated instruments to ascertain acceptable levels of oxygen and acceptable levels of flammable or toxic vapours;

However, different organization have given different interpretations of the above regulations.

Some ships can pass the PSC inspection with one gas detector, while some PSCOS will explicitly require two on board. However, Some P&I Clubs generally recommend 2 gas detectors be carried onboard.

For safety reasons, it is best to have 2 sets of gas detectors onboard. One point to note is that the simple multi-purpose gas detector carried by personnel entering the closed spaces cannot be used as a pre-entry gas test.

General neglect of adjacent connected spaces

We have been paying attention to the closed spaces, and the rules also mentioned some adjacent connected spaces should also be treated in accordance with the enclosed spaces, such as mooring line storage locker, paint locker, SOPEP room, CO2 room, bosun store, etc., usually these rooms are set up with ventilation fans or vent, if the crew does not understand or negligence and suddenly enter, the same will bring fatal injuries.

Other high-risk operations

Closed space is not just to enter inside for inspection only, but means to carry out a variety of high-risk operations, for example, sometimes may be accompanied by high-risk operations such as work at height, hot work, painting work, etc. Some accidents occur in the process of climbing ladders, which is also easy to ignore, So when working inside a closed spaces, in addition to paying attention to the regular risks, you have to be careful of other additional risks and take more stringent safety measures than other high-risk operations on deck in order to avoid accidents.

In addition, some ships have had accidents in which crew members were injured by falling through the manhole of the enclosed spaces, so it is also important to isolate the operation area of the enclosed spaces, and it is recommended to make special protective rails.

Enclosed space rescue

The golden time for rescue in the closed spaces is 4 minutes, according to the rules need a person on guard outside, if there is danger inside, from the beginning of the report to the rescue team gathered to rescue, how many crew members can complete the above operation within 4 minutes? This is why we see reports, as long as it is involved in closed spaces accidents, most of them are fatal cases, and there are few examples of successful rescue, even according to the Convention every two months to do the closed spaces rescue exercises. Considering the complexity of the enclosed space structure, it is questionable whether the crew will be able to assist quickly when someone collapses in the enclosed space.

Is the work permit checklist reasonable?

Many ships that have had accidents have completed the enclosed spaces entry checklists, but why did the crew not following them? The checklist recommended by IMO is more than 3 pages long. Can you imagine the crew members have to complete the enclosed space entry checklist every time he’s doing the enclosed space operation? Crew members have to complete the enclosed space entry checklist, toolbox meeting and risk assessment. All these checklists may add up to 10 pages. Perhaps some of the forms are not practical and it’s just a solution for the management to shirk the responsibility. Hence, crews are reluctant to perform.

On-shore supervision

When the shipping industry implemented 0.5% low sulfur fuel oil in 2020, many ships carried out fuel oil tank cleaning work, and this work involves a lot of closed spaces operations, why there was not much increase in accidents tat that time? This issue is worth thinking about, and I think one very important reason is that the whole industry was paying attention to this matter at that time, and the management company also paid attention to it, and naturally the crew also raised their safety awareness. Therefore, it is highly recommended to notify the company when the ship is carrying out the higher risk of closed spaces operation, which may avoid many accidents.

Who should be blamed after an accident

When an accident occurs, we can’t just complain about the lack of compliance with operating procedures on board, but can we also look for the causes of supervision ashore? For example, does the PSC inspection checklist include the contents of the enclosed spaces entry? does the Class external audit look at the marking of the enclosed spaces and the completion of the work permit? and do the IMO and the flag state consult the front-line crew when setting the rules for access to the enclosed spaces?

The above discussion is based on my practical experience, the analysis may not be correct, my purpose is to hope that we all pay serious attention to the safety hazards of closed spaces, and work together to find solutions. All rules and procedures can be better implemented only if the user recognizes its importance, which is the root of the problem.

 

The views presented are only those of the author and do not necessarily reflect those of SAFETY4SEA and are for information sharing and discussion purposes only.

Who is to blame for the repeated occurrence of accidents in enclosed space?Who is to blame for the repeated occurrence of accidents in enclosed space?
Who is to blame for the repeated occurrence of accidents in enclosed space?Who is to blame for the repeated occurrence of accidents in enclosed space?
Tags: enclosed space entrysafety measures
Previous Post

China announces changes to Chinese crew repatriation procedure

Next Post

7 dead after fire erupted on ferry

Capt. Zhao Qingwei

Capt. Zhao Qingwei

Captain Zhao Qingwei is the head of safety supervision department of Chinaland shipping pte ltd which is a Singapore-based company controlling a fleet of more than 50 bulk and general vessels with 3 million DWT. He is also a master mariner and a member of The Nautical Institute. In addition, he is the local correspondent of Xinde Marine News which is the most influential maritime media in China.

SUGGESTED FOR YOU

emergency stop
Loss Prevention

NMA: Emergency stop & regular function testing of safety devices

July 3, 2025
Persian Gulf
Loss Prevention

West P&I Club: Navigating the Persian Gulf in 2025

June 27, 2025
CINS
Loss Prevention

CINS issues guidance on shipping lithium-ion cells in containers

June 23, 2025
Maersk Israel
Ports

Maersk suspends vessel calls at the Port of Haifa, Israel

June 20, 2025
BSEE
Alerts

BSEE: Bypassed safety device deficiencies and noncompliance

June 11, 2025
BSEE safety alert
Alerts

BSEE: Conduct thorough job safety analysis for all lifting operations

June 10, 2025

Comments 2

  1. Bryce Lawrence says:
    3 years ago

    Whilst there is a lot to be said for lack of accountability of masters and management ashore, one point I think needs to be thought about.

    The STCW Basic Safety Training Certificate does not provide a seafarer with anywhere near the required knowledge to know how to either safely identify what a confined space is, let alone enter a confined space.

    Any example where seafarers being let down by industry that doesn’t value it’s humans.

    Reply
  2. Thaw Da Htay says:
    3 years ago

    Thanks for the facts high lighted in the article. What I wish to mention my view which might be helpful to training centers is…TCs in a way are to perform exercises as realistic as possible in regard of safe entry. But for example… buying a scrap portion of ship DB tanks or building a cargo tank or DB tank in a pattern as close as to ship board one to train or carry out entry exercises will cost dearly to TC. There might be afew. I have read somewhere that in Germany they built something to train rescue and entry operations but with ply wood thick enough to suit the purposes. If such things are officially allowed in TCs, I think that will help somehow reduce the accident rate due to possible safe but trained as close as to reality and affordable by TCs.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Explore more

No Result
View All Result
MARITIME EVENTS

Explore

  • Safety
  • SEAFiT
  • Green
  • Smart
  • Risk
  • Others
  • SAFETY4SEA Events
  • SAFETY4SEA Plus Subscription

Useful Links

  • About
  • Disclaimer
  • Editorial Policies
  • Advertising
  • Content Marketing
  • Contact

© 2025 SAFETY4SEA

No Result
View All Result
  • Safety
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
  • SEAFiT
    • Intellectual
    • Mental
    • Physical
    • Social
    • Spiritual
  • Green
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
  • Smart
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
  • Risk
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Case Studies
    • PSC Focus
    • Vetting
  • Others
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
  • Columns
    • Anchor Your Health
    • Book Review
    • Career Paths
    • Human Performance
    • Industry Voices
    • Interviews
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Opinions
    • Regulatory Update
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
    • Tip of the day
    • Training & Development
    • Wellness Corner
    • Wellness Tips
  • SAFETY4SEA Events
  • SAFETY4SEA Plus Subscription

© 2025 SAFETY4SEA

Manage your privacy
We use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. We do this to improve browsing experience and to show (non-) personalized ads. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behavior or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Manage options
{title} {title} {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Safety
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
  • SEAFiT
    • Intellectual
    • Mental
    • Physical
    • Social
    • Spiritual
  • Green
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
  • Smart
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
  • Risk
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Case Studies
    • PSC Focus
    • Vetting
  • Others
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
  • Columns
    • Anchor Your Health
    • Book Review
    • Career Paths
    • Human Performance
    • Industry Voices
    • Interviews
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Opinions
    • Regulatory Update
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
    • Tip of the day
    • Training & Development
    • Wellness Corner
    • Wellness Tips
  • SAFETY4SEA Events
  • SAFETY4SEA Plus Subscription

© 2025 SAFETY4SEA