Subscribe to our Mailing Lists (It's free!)
Wednesday, June 29, 2022
SAFETY4SEA
  • Home
  • Safety
    • All
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
    fobas

    Off specification sediment fuels found in Amsterdam, Rotterdam, Antwerp region

    norwegian sun

    Cruise ship curtails cruise after ice hit

    bsee lessons learned

    Lessons learned: Improperly maintained fluids in well control equipment systems

    bsee lessons learned

    Lessons learned: Unsecured pressurized hoses result in hand injuries

  • Green
    • All
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
    port of rotterdam

    Green hydrogen import terminal to be developed in Rotterdam

    acua ocean

    Autonomous hydrogen-fueled MASS gets approval

    Motorboat Collides With Barge Tow

    Research center in Saudi Arabia to use AI for development of low-carbon solutions

    fso safer

    Watch: UN coordinator calls public to help in “FSO Safer” emergency operation funding

  • Smart
    • All
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
    acua ocean

    Autonomous hydrogen-fueled MASS gets approval

    Motorboat Collides With Barge Tow

    Research center in Saudi Arabia to use AI for development of low-carbon solutions

    remotely piloted aircrafts

    Iceland uses EMSA’s drones for better maritime situational awareness

    carnival cyber security

    Carnival Corporation fined $5M for failed cyber-security protections

  • Risk
    • All
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Focus
    master first officer fined

    Master, First Officer to pay $75,000 for compliance breach in Great Barrier Reef

    carnival cyber security

    Carnival Corporation fined $5M for failed cyber-security protections

    yang ming hmm

    US shipper accuses Yang Ming and HMM of collusion

    paris mou

    Paris MoU refuses access to ship after skipping Ukrainian repair call because of waiting time

  • Others
    • All
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Reports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
    us stops tanker

    US stops to check tanker arriving from Russia

    shipping costs

    UNCTAD: Ukraine war increases shipping costs

    port of rotterdam

    Green hydrogen import terminal to be developed in Rotterdam

    fso safer

    Watch: UN coordinator calls public to help in “FSO Safer” emergency operation funding

  • Columns
    New requirements for vessels arriving in the port of Singapore during COVID-19

    A changing role of insurers in bunker contamination cases

    Microplastics: tiny plastic, big problem

    Marine plastic pollution – will nurdles be classified under the IMDG code?

    declaration of dangerous goods

    Tech checks proper declaration of dangerous goods

    Trending Tags

    • Career Paths
    • Industry Voices
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
  • Events
  • Plus
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Safety
    • All
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
    fobas

    Off specification sediment fuels found in Amsterdam, Rotterdam, Antwerp region

    norwegian sun

    Cruise ship curtails cruise after ice hit

    bsee lessons learned

    Lessons learned: Improperly maintained fluids in well control equipment systems

    bsee lessons learned

    Lessons learned: Unsecured pressurized hoses result in hand injuries

  • Green
    • All
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
    port of rotterdam

    Green hydrogen import terminal to be developed in Rotterdam

    acua ocean

    Autonomous hydrogen-fueled MASS gets approval

    Motorboat Collides With Barge Tow

    Research center in Saudi Arabia to use AI for development of low-carbon solutions

    fso safer

    Watch: UN coordinator calls public to help in “FSO Safer” emergency operation funding

  • Smart
    • All
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
    acua ocean

    Autonomous hydrogen-fueled MASS gets approval

    Motorboat Collides With Barge Tow

    Research center in Saudi Arabia to use AI for development of low-carbon solutions

    remotely piloted aircrafts

    Iceland uses EMSA’s drones for better maritime situational awareness

    carnival cyber security

    Carnival Corporation fined $5M for failed cyber-security protections

  • Risk
    • All
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Focus
    master first officer fined

    Master, First Officer to pay $75,000 for compliance breach in Great Barrier Reef

    carnival cyber security

    Carnival Corporation fined $5M for failed cyber-security protections

    yang ming hmm

    US shipper accuses Yang Ming and HMM of collusion

    paris mou

    Paris MoU refuses access to ship after skipping Ukrainian repair call because of waiting time

  • Others
    • All
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Reports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
    us stops tanker

    US stops to check tanker arriving from Russia

    shipping costs

    UNCTAD: Ukraine war increases shipping costs

    port of rotterdam

    Green hydrogen import terminal to be developed in Rotterdam

    fso safer

    Watch: UN coordinator calls public to help in “FSO Safer” emergency operation funding

  • Columns
    New requirements for vessels arriving in the port of Singapore during COVID-19

    A changing role of insurers in bunker contamination cases

    Microplastics: tiny plastic, big problem

    Marine plastic pollution – will nurdles be classified under the IMDG code?

    declaration of dangerous goods

    Tech checks proper declaration of dangerous goods

    Trending Tags

    • Career Paths
    • Industry Voices
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Resilience
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
  • Events
  • Plus
No Result
View All Result
SAFETY4SEA

Princess of the Orient: Erroneous maneuvering leads to deadly sinking

by The Editorial Team
December 10, 2019
in Accidents
princess of the orient

Credit: Pinqui

FacebookTwitterEmailLinkedin

The Philippines has a long history of fatal maritime accidents. This time, SAFETY4SEA focuses on the deadly sinking of the ‘Princess of the Orient’. The ferry sank off Fortune Island, near the provinces of Cavite and Batangas, on September 18, 1998, claiming the lives of 150 people. Extreme weather conditions, along with ‘’erroneous maneuvering of the vessel by the captain’’, were the immediate causes of the accident.

The incident

On September 18, 1998, the Princess of the Orient starts its voyage from Manila to Cebu during typhoon Vicki, carrying a total of 388 passengers.

Two hours after leaving the Manila harbor, the ferry suddenly tilted to its port side and was unable to recover. Initially, a list of three degrees was observed at the portside, which had continuously increased. At the same, time, winds and waves were hitting the ship on its starboard side. The waves were at least seven to eight meters in height and the wind velocity was 25 knots.

RelatedNews

Cruise ship curtails cruise after ice hit

Lessons learned: Improperly maintained fluids in well control equipment systems

It eventually capsized at 12:55 a.m. near Fortune Island and sank, with 150 people losing their lives.

GET THE SAFETY4SEA IN YOUR INBOX!

Napoleon Sesante, then a member of the Philippine National Police (PNP) and a lawyer, was one of the passengers who survived the sinking, and provided a description of what was happening that day. Mr. Sesante sued Sulpicio Lines, which owned and operated the vessel, for breach of contract and damages.

In his complaint Mr. Sesante claimed that the M/V Princess of the Orient left the Port of Manila while Metro Manila was experiencing stormy weather. He had also noticed that the ship was listing starboard, while other passenger were panicking. In his complaint he also describes that the vessel was hit by big waves.

Fatalities

Of the 388 passengers, 150 died when the ship sank.

As for the survivors, they floated at sea for more than 12 hours before rescuers were able to reach them.

Probable cause

According to the report of the Board of Marine Inquiry (BMI), ‘the erroneous maneuvering of the vessel by the captain during the extreme weather condition had been the immediate and proximate cause of the sinking.’

However, when the ship started sailing, it was navigating smoothly towards Limbones Point, experiencing normal weather.

When it entered the Manila Bar, the waves were observed to be relatively small to endanger the safety of the ship.

However, upon leaving Limbones Pt., and heading towards the Fortune Island, misfortune struck the ship.

Initially, a list of three degrees was observed. The listing of the ship to her portside had continuously increased. It was at this point that the captain had misjudged the situation.

As the Supreme Court of Manila noted, while the vessel was facing extreme weather, ‘prudent judgement would dictate that the Captain should have considerably reduced the ship’s speed.’

In addition, due to the excessive movement, the solid and liquid cargo below the decks must have shifted its weight to port, contributing to the tilted position of the ship.

A little later, the Captain ordered to reduce the speed of the ship to 14 knots, while also ordering to put ballast water to the starboard-heeling tank, hoping to stop the continuous listing of the ship. However, this action was in vein, as the vessel was already listing between 15 to 20 degrees to her portside, and was about to lose its stability.

In spite of being in a dangerous situation, the Captain performed various starboard maneuvers, which added to the ship’s tilting. As the ‘Princess of the Orient’ was already inclined to an angle of 15 degrees, along with the instantaneous movement of the ship, the cargoes below deck could have completely shifted its position and weight towards portside.

Court ruling

On October 12, 2001, the Regional Trial Court (RTC) decided in favor of Napoleon Sesante:

Judgment is hereby rendered in favor of plaintiff Napoleon Sesante and against defendant Sulpicio Lines, Inc.

The court ordered the company to pay Mr. Sesante:

  • Temperate damages in the amount of P400,000.00;
  • Moral damages in the amount of One Million Pesos;
  • Costs of suit.

More specifically, explaining its decision, the RTC observed that the Sulpicio Lines:

  • Had not established its due diligence in the selection and supervision of the vessel crew;
  • The ship officers had failed to inspect the stowage of cargoes despite being aware of the storm signal;
  • The officers and crew of the vessel had not immediately sent a distress signal to the Philippine Coast Guard;
  • The ship captain had not called for then “abandon ship” protocol;
  • Based on the report of the Board of Marine Inquiry (BMI), the erroneous maneuvering of the vessel by the captain during the extreme weather condition had been the immediate and proximate cause of the sinking.

The company sought reconsideration, but the RTC only partly granted its motion, reducing the temperate damages from P500,000.00 to P300,000.00.

As a result, the company appealed in the Court of Appeals (CA). On June 27, 2005, the CA held the RTC’s decision, but lowered the temperate damages to P120,000.00, which approximated the cost of Mr. Sesante’s lost personal belongings. It also judged that in spite of the seaworthiness of the vessel, Sulpicio Lines remained civilly liable because its officers and crew had been negligent in performing their duties.

Finally, the company took the case to the Supreme Court of Manila, which however decided that the appeal lacked merit.

 

LEARN FROM THE PAST: Read in this series

Halifax Harbour: One of the largest human-made explosions caused by ships’ collision

Halifax Harbour: One of the largest human-made explosions caused by ships’ collision

May 10, 2022
Sinking of Doña Paz: The world’s deadliest shipping accident

Sinking of Doña Paz: The world’s deadliest shipping accident

March 8, 2022
Wilhelm Gustloff: A forgotten ‘war loss’ of over 9,000 people

Wilhelm Gustloff: A forgotten ‘war loss’ of over 9,000 people

February 14, 2022
Scandinavian Star ferry

Tampomas II: Remembering Indonesia’s deadly ferry sinking

February 10, 2022
Hoegh Osaka accident is a stark warning accident

Hoegh Osaka: Assessing ship stability must not be neglected

January 10, 2022
MV Derbyshire

MV Derbyshire: Remembering largest British ship ever lost at sea

October 4, 2021
Titanic SOLAS

Remembering Titanic: The tragedy behind SOLAS

April 12, 2021
wakashio

MV Wakashio oil spill: A timeline of events in an environmental disaster

February 11, 2021
princess of the orient

Princess of the Orient: Erroneous maneuvering leads to deadly sinking

December 10, 2019
Achille Lauro

Achille Lauro hijacking: A tragic example of maritime terrorism

December 10, 2019
al salam boccaccio 98

Al-Salam Boccaccio 98: Bad weather, poor emergency procedures and over 1,000 people dead in Red Sea

November 28, 2019
Alexander L Kielland

Alexander L. Kielland: Norway’s worst offshore disaster

November 19, 2019
USS Fitzgerald

USS Fitzgerald deadly collision: Poor seamanship in the spotlight

October 22, 2019
piper alpha

Piper Alpha: The world’s deadliest offshore oil disaster

October 17, 2019
amoco cadiz

Amoco Cadiz oil spill: The largest loss of marine life ever

October 8, 2019
estonia sinking

MS Estonia sinking: One of the deadliest accidents in European waters

October 4, 2019
torrey canyon

Torrey Canyon: The world’s first major oil tanker disaster

October 3, 2019
Sanchi

Sanchi: The world’s worst oil tanker disaster in decades

September 27, 2019
el faro

El Faro sinking: Poor seamanship in the spotlight

September 25, 2019
uss john s mccain

USS John S McCain collision: A prime example of poor oversight

September 23, 2019
bulk jupiter

Bulk Jupiter sinking: A stark reminder of bauxite cargo risks

September 20, 2019
ovit grounding

Ovit grounding: ECDIS incompetence and inexperienced crew in vital positions

June 7, 2019
oliva

MS Oliva grounding: Oil spill in one of the world’s most remote areas

May 27, 2019
Cosco Busan

Cosco Busan: Lack of communication, poor oversight and 53,500 gallons of oil in San Francisco Bay

May 21, 2019
viking islay

Viking Islay enclosed space fatalities: Rescuers becoming victims

May 20, 2019
pasha bulker

Pasha Bulker beaching: A mix of poor SMS, fatigue and bad weather

May 17, 2019
bourbon dolphin

Bourbon Dolphin: A tragic example of ISM non-compliance

May 14, 2019
harvest caroline

Harvest Caroline: A case study on improper safety management

May 10, 2019
cougar ace

Cougar Ace: How improper ballast water exchange can prove costly

May 8, 2019
herald of free enterprise

Herald of Free Enterprise: A wake-up call for Ro-Ro safety

April 25, 2019
MT Haven

MT Haven: The worst oil spill ever in the Mediterranean

April 18, 2019
sewol

Sewol sinking: South Korea’s ferry disaster

April 16, 2019
Moby Prince

Moby Prince: Italy’s worst maritime disaster since World War II

April 10, 2019
Stellar Daisy

Learn from the past: Stellar Daisy sinking

April 1, 2019
Superferry14

Superferry14: The world’s deadliest terrorist attack at sea

February 27, 2019
Scandinavian Star ferry

Ocean Ranger: Commemorating North America’s offshore disaster

February 15, 2019
Marine Electric

Marine Electric: The sinking that changed USCG approach on safety

February 12, 2019
erika oil spill

Learn from the past: Erika oil spill, Europe’s environmental disaster

December 12, 2018
prestige sinking

Learn from the past: Prestige sinking, one of the worst oil spills in Europe

November 13, 2018
salvage of mega box ships

Learn from the past: MV Rena grounding

October 29, 2018
eurasian dream

Maritime History: Fire on board car carrier “Eurasian Dream”

July 23, 2018
princess of the stars

Learn from the past: The Princess of the Seas deadly sinking

June 22, 2018
offshore safety rules

Learn from the past: Deepwater Horizon oil spill

April 20, 2018
Scandinavian Star ferry

Learn from the past: Exxon Valdez incident

March 23, 2018
Scandinavian Star ferry

Learn from the past: Bow Mariner incident

February 28, 2018
Costa Concordia

Maritime history: Costa Concordia disaster

January 13, 2018

 


cyber security in shipping industrySulpicio Lines has been involved in several other maritime casualties, including the Dona Paz sinking, which is the deadliest ever peacetime shipping disaster, with 4,386 fatalities. It is estimated that four marine tragedies involving Sulpicio vessels have resulted in death of about 5,000 people in the last decades.

 


Timeline of the deadliest shipping disasters in the Philippines

Dec 1987 – A total of 4,386 die in world’s worst peacetime shipping disaster, after Dona Paz and an oil tanker collide off Mindoro Island.

Oct 1988 – Dona Marilyn, sister ship of Dona Paz, sinks off Leyte province, killing around 300.

July 1993 – 279 pilgrims drown when an overloaded wooden temple, mounted on three boats, collapses during a religious festival as it is being towed along the Bocaue river, 20 km (12 miles) north of Manila.

Dec 1994 – Ferry Cebu City collides with Singapore oil tanker, killing more than 140.

Sept 1998 – Almost 200 die when the ferry ‘Princess of the Orient’, sister ship of Dona Paz and Dona Marilyn, sinks in stormy seas near Cavite and Batangas.

April 2000 – At least 138 drown after the ML Annahada sinks off Jolo island in the southern part of the country.

February 2004 – Superferry 14 catches fire near Manila Bay, killing 116 people. Abu Sayyaf claims responsibility, saying a suicide bomber sabotaged the boat to protest ill treatment of Muslim communities.

June 2008 – Princess of Stars sinks 3 km from Sibuyan island, killing about 800 people.

Sept 2009 – SuperFerry 9 sank off Zamboanga Peninsula killing 10 people.

 

Tags: capsized vesselfatality onboardhazardous weather at seahuman elementlessons learnedMaritime HistoryPhilippinessmvessel sinks

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recommended

us stops tanker

US stops to check tanker arriving from Russia

June 29, 2022
shipping costs

UNCTAD: Ukraine war increases shipping costs

June 29, 2022
MARITIME EVENTS

Newsletter

GET THE SAFETY4SEA IN YOUR INBOX!

Explore

  • Safety
  • Green
  • Smart
  • Risk
  • Others
  • Events
  • Plus

Useful Links

  • About
  • Disclaimer
  • Editorial Policies
  • Advertising
  • Contact

© 2021 SAFETY4SEA

No Result
View All Result
  • Safety
    • Alerts
    • Accidents
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security
  • Green
    • Arctic
    • Ballast
    • Emissions
    • Fuels
    • Green Shipping
    • Pollution
    • Ship Recycling
    • Technology
  • Smart
    • Connectivity
    • Cyber Security
    • E-navigation
    • Energy Efficiency
    • Maritime Software
    • Smart
  • Risk
    • CIC
    • Detentions
    • Fines
    • PSC Focus
    • Vetting
  • Others
    • Diversity in shipping
    • Maritime Knowledge
    • Offshore
    • Ports
    • Reports
    • Shipping
    • Sustainability
    • Videos
  • Columns
    • Opinions
    • Career Paths
    • Industry Voices
    • Maripedia
    • Maritime History
    • Seafarers Stories
    • SeaSense
  • Events
  • Plus

© 2021 SAFETY4SEA

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Disclaimer.