Subscribe to our Mailing Lists (It's free!)
Friday, April 23, 2021
No Result
View All Result
SAFETY4SEA
  • Home
  • Safety
    • All
    • Accidents
    • Alerts
    • Loss Prevention
    • Maritime Health
    • Regulation
    • Safety
    • Seafarers
    • Security

    New Zealand’s legislation on seafarer welfare funding effective from July

    collision in channel

    NTSB investigation: Collision in channel leads to vessel total loss

    rmi marine casualties

    RMI reports 726 marine casualties and incidents in 2020

    Trending Tags

    • Green
      • All
      • Arctic
      • Ballast
      • Emissions
      • Fuels
      • Green Shipping
      • Pollution
      • Ship Recycling
      • Technology
      us carbon emissions reduction

      US announces plan to reduce CO2 emissions 50% by 2030

      first engineer convicted

      First Engineer convicted after oil dumping from tanker in US

      New value chain analysis from ABS on alternative marine fuels

      New value chain analysis from ABS on alternative marine fuels

      Trending Tags

      • Smart
        • All
        • Connectivity
        • Cyber Security
        • E-navigation
        • Energy Efficiency
        • Maritime Software
        • Smart
        electrical engineering regulations

        USCG proposes update to electrical engineering regulations

        gmdss Worldwide Navigational Warnings Service

        USCG: Overview of GMDSS Worldwide Navigational Warnings Service

        China Merchants Port

        China Merchants Port takes autonomous trucking a step further

        Trending Tags

        • Risk
          • All
          • CIC
          • Detentions
          • Fines
          • PSC Focus
          ships detained in uk

          List of ships detained in the UK in March 2021

          paris mou detentions

          List of ships detained in Paris MoU in March 2021

          shanghai

          Shanghai launches CIC on propulsion and auxiliary machinery

          Trending Tags

          • Others
            • All
            • Diversity in shipping
            • Maritime Knowledge
            • Offshore
            • Ports
            • Reports
            • Shipping
            • Sustainability
            • Videos
            ECSA

            ECSA welcomes recognition of shipping as a transitional sector

            soft skills and safety

            Book of the month: The link of soft skills to organizational safety

            underwater noise notation

            First vessel granted quiet underwater operations notation by DNV

            Trending Tags

            • Columns
              safety culture

              Waste of Space : A fresh look into Bridge Design

              TT Club Suez Canal

              “EVER GIVEN” Suez Delays: Who pays for the consequences?

              maritime nz update

              COVID-19 and bill of lading fraud

              Trending Tags

              • Career Paths
              • Industry Voices
              • Maripedia
              • Maritime History
              • Resilience
              • Seafarers Stories
              • SeaSense
            • Events
            • Plus
            • Home
            • Safety
              • All
              • Accidents
              • Alerts
              • Loss Prevention
              • Maritime Health
              • Regulation
              • Safety
              • Seafarers
              • Security

              New Zealand’s legislation on seafarer welfare funding effective from July

              collision in channel

              NTSB investigation: Collision in channel leads to vessel total loss

              rmi marine casualties

              RMI reports 726 marine casualties and incidents in 2020

              Trending Tags

              • Green
                • All
                • Arctic
                • Ballast
                • Emissions
                • Fuels
                • Green Shipping
                • Pollution
                • Ship Recycling
                • Technology
                us carbon emissions reduction

                US announces plan to reduce CO2 emissions 50% by 2030

                first engineer convicted

                First Engineer convicted after oil dumping from tanker in US

                New value chain analysis from ABS on alternative marine fuels

                New value chain analysis from ABS on alternative marine fuels

                Trending Tags

                • Smart
                  • All
                  • Connectivity
                  • Cyber Security
                  • E-navigation
                  • Energy Efficiency
                  • Maritime Software
                  • Smart
                  electrical engineering regulations

                  USCG proposes update to electrical engineering regulations

                  gmdss Worldwide Navigational Warnings Service

                  USCG: Overview of GMDSS Worldwide Navigational Warnings Service

                  China Merchants Port

                  China Merchants Port takes autonomous trucking a step further

                  Trending Tags

                  • Risk
                    • All
                    • CIC
                    • Detentions
                    • Fines
                    • PSC Focus
                    ships detained in uk

                    List of ships detained in the UK in March 2021

                    paris mou detentions

                    List of ships detained in Paris MoU in March 2021

                    shanghai

                    Shanghai launches CIC on propulsion and auxiliary machinery

                    Trending Tags

                    • Others
                      • All
                      • Diversity in shipping
                      • Maritime Knowledge
                      • Offshore
                      • Ports
                      • Reports
                      • Shipping
                      • Sustainability
                      • Videos
                      ECSA

                      ECSA welcomes recognition of shipping as a transitional sector

                      soft skills and safety

                      Book of the month: The link of soft skills to organizational safety

                      underwater noise notation

                      First vessel granted quiet underwater operations notation by DNV

                      Trending Tags

                      • Columns
                        safety culture

                        Waste of Space : A fresh look into Bridge Design

                        TT Club Suez Canal

                        “EVER GIVEN” Suez Delays: Who pays for the consequences?

                        maritime nz update

                        COVID-19 and bill of lading fraud

                        Trending Tags

                        • Career Paths
                        • Industry Voices
                        • Maripedia
                        • Maritime History
                        • Resilience
                        • Seafarers Stories
                        • SeaSense
                      • Events
                      • Plus
                      No Result
                      View All Result
                      SAFETY4SEA
                      No Result
                      View All Result

                      Enclosed space deaths onboard: Why do they persist?

                      by The Editorial Team
                      October 22, 2020
                      in Accidents, Maritime Knowledge
                      enclosed space procedures
                      FacebookTwitterEmailLinkedin

                      The danger associated with enclosed spaces is a main safety concern for shipping, which is struggling to eliminate incidents despite various regulations in place. A recent ITF report revealed a total of 145 casualties in enclosed spaces in the past 20 years. The even alarming fact is that 28 of these casualties happened in the last 16 months.

                      Regulatory landscape at a glance

                      • Mandatory drills for enclosed space, under SOLAS, came into force on January 2015.
                      • From July 2016, gas detector equipment must be available onboard ships.
                      • ISM Code requires companies to ensure that proper risk assessment and procedures are in place to prevent such incidents.
                      • The 6th edition of ISGOTT came out in June 2020, following the 5th edition in 2006, incorporating all the changes made by IMO through these years and including also enclosed spaces.

                      Although the ISM Code has set the ground of ship safety for years and despite more specific regulations in place to prevent confined space fatalities, we continue to see these types of casualties. So what is wrong? This question was at the center of a special session organized by The Standard P&I Club in cooperation with Intermanager earlier in October. 

                      RelatedNews

                      NTSB investigation: Collision in channel leads to vessel total loss

                      RMI reports 726 marine casualties and incidents in 2020

                       

                      Why enclosed space deaths onboard persist?

                      An Intermanager survey of 2018 to 5,000 seafarers, including only one question ‘why do you kill yourself in enclosed spaces?’ identified the following causes:

                      1. By far many and conflicted procedures were identified as the key cause. Each company has its own SMS, while there is a wide mix of different people onboard who are confused with the variety of information.

                      From shoreside, we need to stop confusing people. Issue less documents. After every investigation, there is a plethora of new circulars. We have got enough. Let’s concentrate on these to start with,

                      …said Capt. Kuba Szymanski, Secretary General, InterManager.

                      1. Enclosed space design

                      If we were to go for those two, then we would really make an impact.

                      1. Personnel: Very often, people onboard do not know each other. They normally wont’ say, “Stop! Don’t go” and they may want to impress their mates by doing silly things.
                      2. Training
                      3. Technology
                      4. Safety culture
                      5. Commercial pressure
                      6. Fear factor
                      7. Definitions
                      8. The EEBD

                      We keep killing people. This means that, whatever we are doing as shore personnel, we are not doing it right. We are not hitting the root cause. We are not eradicating it, we are just barking the wrong tree,

                      …noted Capt. Szymanski.

                       

                      What about the enclosed space rescue?

                      I think the official term is a “fight of flight reaction”. People do not consciously think what they should do and they just instinctively react and go inside,

                      …noted Capt. Yves Vandenborn, Director of Loss Prevention, Standard Club, who moderated the discussion.

                      There have been several cases, where the crew enters these spaces with an EEBD, respirators, or gas masks, which are not the appropriate equipment. EEBD is for escape, not for rescue. Likewise, the respirators or gas masks are not designed to supply air; they are only useful when working in a dusty environment, but not for oxygen deficiency or toxic gases, explained Capt. Akshat Arora, Senior Surveyor, Standard Club.

                      So what is the appropriate equipment?

                      A Master’s Guide to Enclosed Space Entry by The Standard Club says the appropriate safety and rescue equipment for entering an enclosed space may vary depending upon the space, ship type and work involved.

                      As a minimum, it will usually include:

                      • SCBA (self-contained breathing apparatus) with a spare cylinder
                      • life line and rescue harnesses
                      • lighting, including torches
                      • stretcher
                      • means of raising stretcher, ie tripod
                      • type arrangement
                      • communication equipment
                      • appropriate atmosphere testing equipment and personal gas meters.

                      “An EEBD (emergency escape breathing device) should never be used in lieu of a SCBA set. They can only be used as an escape device. Appropriate personal protection equipment (PPE), including a personal gas meter, should be worn by all personnel entering the enclosed space.”

                      There is a consistent theme that we see where most of the drills are actually carried out for the sake of paper exercise or ‘tick the box’. They are not realistic, they are not challenging and they don’t make the people think outside of the book,

                      …added Capt. Arora.

                       

                      Enclosed space: The hierarchy of controls

                      Who is responsible to give an order to the crew to go to a tank, knowing that this tank may not be sufficient?

                      According to Capt. Szymanski, the crew onboard is the least responsible, as PPE and Procedures are the field where the crew can have a say. The industry seems to be concentrating at PPE and procedures all the time instead of moving up to the triangle.

                      Why do we need hundreds to die before we start thinking there is something wrong with these spaces?

                      Capt. Szymanski advocates that the industry should focus on two things:

                      1. Accident investigations with human beings in mind and
                      2. Human-centric design.

                      Stop blaming humans. Humans are actually helpful. We don’t know how many times humans actually helped an incident not to happen. We only concentrate when there is something wrong happening.

                      P&I Clubs have a role to play in this, by stop focusing on seafarer training and start thinking about training for chief executives, Capt. Szymanski stressed.

                       

                      Enclosed space issues in the COVID-19 era

                      Amid COVID-19 pandemic, fumigation specialists refrain from embarking on ships as they do not know where they will be able to disembark, so crew are required to do this kind of work, in opposition to IMO requirements and even though they are not trained to do fumigation topping up. And an LOI which will be put in place covers only potential cargo damages, not lives of seafarers.

                      What we recommend is operators to make sure that the crew are well trained and well aware of the hazards that they are going to be exposed to. Secondly, they need to be well aware of the gas detector tubes,

                      …noted Capt. Arora.

                      And most importantly, as the IMO circular very clearly says that it should not be handled by crew, but only by qualified operator, they need to get a flag state permission. Unless they have one, the LOI is not sufficient.

                      From the shoreside perspective, Capt. Szymanski recommended the HSCQ manager to read and actually understand safety data sheets and then asking themselves a question: “Are my ships equipped to do that?”

                      We cannot be a post-office in the ship management company where we receive one paper, send it to the ship and the ship will digest and tell us something. No, it won’t. It’s our responsibility to make sure we have got the data sheets and very often we don’t,

                      …he stressed.

                      • Keynote advice for crew managers: Listen to crew members; they are your most valuable advisors. Encourage your crew members to speak up, even though you don’t like what they say.

                      • Keynote advice for crew: Don’t be shy. Believe that you can make a change. You have all instruments available.

                       

                      Find also a Master’s Guide to Enclosed Space Entry by The Standard Club here:

                      Standard Club guide
                      Tags: enclosed space entryfatality onboardInterManagerISM Codereportssafety measuresStandard Clubtraining

                      Leave a Reply Cancel reply

                      Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

                      Recommended

                      New Zealand’s legislation on seafarer welfare funding effective from July

                      April 23, 2021
                      collision in channel

                      NTSB investigation: Collision in channel leads to vessel total loss

                      April 23, 2021
                      MARITIME EVENTS

                      Most Read

                      • enclosed space design

                        Emergency Procedures: Rescue from Enclosed Space

                        0 shares
                        Share 0 Tweet 0
                      • Bulk Jupiter sinking: A stark reminder of bauxite cargo risks

                        0 shares
                        Share 0 Tweet 0
                      • Do you know what are the biggest ships of the world?

                        0 shares
                        Share 0 Tweet 0
                      • Do you know what NATO phonetic alphabet is?

                        0 shares
                        Share 0 Tweet 0
                      • Insurers Considerations for Autonomous Ships

                        0 shares
                        Share 0 Tweet 0

                      Newsletter

                      GET THE SAFETY4SEA IN YOUR INBOX!

                      Explore

                      • Safety
                      • Green
                      • Smart
                      • Risk
                      • Others
                      • Events
                      • Plus

                      Useful Links

                      • About
                      • Disclaimer
                      • Editorial Policies
                      • Advertising
                      • Contact

                      © 2021 SAFETY4SEA

                      No Result
                      View All Result
                      • Safety
                        • Alerts
                        • Accidents
                        • Loss Prevention
                        • Maritime Health
                        • Regulation
                        • Safety
                        • Seafarers
                        • Security
                      • Green
                        • Arctic
                        • Ballast
                        • Emissions
                        • Fuels
                        • Green Shipping
                        • Pollution
                        • Ship Recycling
                        • Technology
                      • Smart
                        • Connectivity
                        • Cyber Security
                        • E-navigation
                        • Energy Efficiency
                        • Maritime Software
                        • Smart
                      • Risk
                        • CIC
                        • Detentions
                        • Fines
                        • PSC Focus
                        • Vetting
                      • Others
                        • Diversity in shipping
                        • Maritime Knowledge
                        • Offshore
                        • Ports
                        • Shipping
                        • Sustainability
                        • Videos
                      • Columns
                        • Opinions
                        • Career Paths
                        • Industry Voices
                        • Maripedia
                        • Maritime History
                        • Seafarers Stories
                        • SeaSense
                      • Events
                      • Plus

                      © 2021 SAFETY4SEA

                      This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Disclaimer.